Bush Aides Possibly Altered National
Guard Records
To Conceal Grounding and Missed
Duty
by Bob Fertik
Aides to Texas Governor George W. Bush visited the Air National Guard
archives at Camp Mabry in 1997 and possibly altered Bush's military
service records to conceal Bush's grounding from flight in 1972 and
subsequent missed duty, according to a former senior official of the
Texas
National Guard.
Bill Burkett, a Lt. Colonel who was the State Plans Officer of the Texas
National Guard at the time, said Bush operative Dan Bartlett headed
a high-
level operation to "scrub" Bush's Air National Guard record, to make
sure
it was in synch with the biography that the campaign was preparing.
The book, "A Charge to Keep," was authored by Bush and his principal
spokeswoman, Karen Hughes. Hughes was recently exposed during the DUI
sidebar involving reporter Wayne Slater as the person who strictly
controls what Bush is allowed to say.
At the time, Bartlett was Governor Bush's liaison to the Texas National
Guard. Bartlett is now the campaign spokesman who has provided misleading
information to the press on several occasions about Bush's military
service.
In "A Charge to Keep," Bush briefly mentioned his National Guard service.
After completing flight training in June 1970, Bush wrote, "I continued
flying with my unit for the next several years."
In fact, according to reports by the Boston Globe, Democrats.com and
TomPaine.com, Bush stopped flying only 22 months later in April 1972.
He
was subsequently grounded from flight on August 1, 1972 because he
"failed
to accomplish his annual physical."
There is no mention of the grounding in Bush's biography, which falsely
implies that Bush continued flying until he left the National Guard.
When questioned by the press, Bush spokesman Dan Bartlett has offered
several different reasons for this grounding. Initially Bartlett said
that
Bush could not get to Houston for his physical, but this was proved
wrong
when it was shown that Bush could have visited flight surgeons stationed
in Alabama. Bartlett then said the F-102 fighter that Bush was trained
to
fly was removed from service, but this was proved wrong when it was
shown
that the F-102 remained in service in Bush's unit for two more years.
Democrats.com has speculated that Bush skipped his annual physical in
1972
because the Pentagon that year imposed random drug testing for the
first time,
and Bush feared he would fail the exam. Bush has admitted drinking
heavily at
the time, and has refused to deny using cocaine before 1974. Similar
allegations
have been reported in the Times of London and the New York Post.
Democrats.com has stressed the significance of Bush's grounding. Bush's
pilot
training cost the government nearly $1 million, and this was a huge
investment that
the Pentagon would not lightly abandon with two years remaining of
a pilot's obligation.
Moreover, pilots were badly needed at the time because of the war in
Vietnam.
According to Democrats.com, Bush's grounding would normally have been
reviewed
by a Flight Inquiry Board of three senior officers, but there is no
record that such a
board was convened in Bush's case. Democrats.com has called for Bush
to reveal
his full military records, to put these and other charges to rest.
Moreover, Democrats.com and TomPaine.com have revealed that Bush did
not
report for duty for at least a year after he stopped flying, and possibly
two years.
Bush's official record shows no duty after April 1972, and his superior
officers in
both Alabama and Texas say they never saw him after that.
An official report issued on April 30, 1973 says "Lt. Bush has not been
observed
at this unit during the period of this report," from May 1 1972 to
April 30, 1973.
Rewards for proof that Bush reported for duty have been offered in
Alabama and
Texas and on the Internet, but no one has claimed the rewards.
During the campaign, Bush has attempted to fend off charges that he
did
not report for duty. When charges were raised about the time he spent
in
Alabama in the fall of 1972, Bush insisted that he reported for duty.
"I
can't remember what I did. I just - I fulfilled my obligation," he
said.
Bush has specifically disputed the recollection of ret. Brig. Gen.
William
Turnipseed, who says he is "dead-certain" that Bush did not report
for
duty in Alabama. ''I read the comments from the guy who said he doesn't
remember me being there, but I remember being there," Bush said.
Internet activists led by Iowa farmer Martin Heldt and retired Air
National Guard pilot Bob Rogers have been campaigning to expose Bush's
failure to report for duty since May 23, 2000, when the Boston Globe
first
reported on a "one-year gap" in Bush's military duty. Heldt created
a
discussion board at Salon Magazine charging that Bush was "AWOL", which
spurred an explosion of grassroots Internet activism.
Heldt and Rogers filed a Freedom of Information Act request for Bush's
military records, which provided overwhelming evidence of Bush's missed
duty, and served as the basis of the articles in Democrats.com and
TomPaine.com.
On Thursday, Congressional Medal of Honor recipients Bob Kerrey and
Daniel
Inouye brought these charges to the attention of the national media,
which has
almost entirely ignored the work of Heldt and Rogers. "The question
is where
were you, Governor Bush?," said Inouye. "During my service, if I missed
training
for two years, at the least, I would have been court- martialed. I
would have
been placed in prison," he said.
To rebut this charge, the Bush campaign has relied on two mysterious
documents. The documents are neither dated nor signed, which makes
their
legitimacy entirely questionable. Moreover, the document that the campaign
claims covers the year from May 1972 to May 1973 is badly torn and
can
only be linked to Lt. George W. Bush by the letter "W". Finally, these
documents are directly contradicted by Bush's official record, several
signed memoranda, and the testimony of several witnesses.
Still, both the New York Times and George Magazine have used these
mysterious documents as the basis for dismissing all of the other documents
and witnesses which overwhelmingly show that Bush did not report for
duty.
Thus, the assertion by Bill Burkett that Dan Bartlett and his operatives
modified Bush's Air National Guard records takes on exceptional
significance. Bartlett's "scrubbing" operation in 1997 could have inserted
these mysterious documents, or removed significant information from
the
torn document. In addition, Bartlett's operation could have removed
or
altered other revealing documents.
Indeed, there is corroborating evidence that Bush campaign operatives
have
devoted considerable effort to "scrubbing" public records to conceal
other
evidence of Bush's wrongdoing. For example, Bush got a new driver's
license
after he was elected Governor, which appears to be completely unprecedented.
This prevented reporters from discovering Bush's DUI arrest in Maine
in 1976.
This new license may also be concealing a subsequent DUI or drug arrest
in
1972 or 1973, when Bush went to work with an inner-city community service
group in Houston called Project PULL. There has been considerable
speculation that Bush performed this work as a form of alternative
sentencing for a DUI or drug arrest, but reporters have been stymied
by
the fact that Bush's 1995 driver's license contains no prior information.
Moreover, Newsweek reported on July 9, 2000 that the Bush campaign
"launched a secretive research operation designed to scour all records
relating
to his Vietnam-era service" during preparation for Bush's 1998 re-election
campaign.
They paid "hard-nosed Dallas lawyer named Harriet Miers" $19,000 to
review the records.
According to Newsweek, one result of her work was to deflect charges
that former
Texas House Speaker Ben Barnes helped Bush get into the Texas Air National
Guard
despite low qualifications and a long waiting list. Barnes was later
forced to testify
under oath that he helped Bush.
The same Newsweek article also discusses the absence of evidence that
Bush
fulfilled his orders to report for duty in Alabama in the fall of 1972.
According to the article, "Dan Bartlett conceded that the records 'were
either lost or misplaced... we are not sure.'" If Burkett's charges
are
true, Bartlett may have had a hand in losing or misplacing these records.
The Newsweek article also credits the Bush operation with locating as
a
corroborating witness "an old girlfriend, Emily Marks, who got to know
Bush in Alabama. Marks said Bush told her he had to go back to Montgomery
after the election to make up some reserve requirements. 'This
corroborates what the governor has been saying,' Bartlett said." However,
Marks told the Decatur Daily that she "never actually drove him to
Guard duty."
Newsweek concluded that: "For the moment, at least, it seemed that Bush’s
damage-control team had gotten matters under control again."
Not any more.