'Wing' Uses Net Asset
By ERIC MINK
Daily News TV Critic
In the Internet-driven 21st century, you
never know what might turn up in the
in-box of your e-mail server.
For writer-producer Aaron Sorkin, it was
a nugget of material that he eventually
transformed into the most riveting,
high-pressure scene of last week's episode
of "The West Wing."
"I was writing the third script," Sorkin
told The News, "which takes place some 12 to
14 weeks after the season opener, around
the time of the midterm elections.
A friend forwarded me a copy of an anonymous
Internet posting in which the
author sarcastically agreed with Dr. Laura
Schlessinger, the controversial talk-radio
host] that homosexuality was an abomination
as cited in Leviticus. He or
she then went on to point out other Old
Testament passages that mentioned
extreme punishments for what today are
some pretty ordinary things."
Sorkin already had written a subplot for
the episode about President Bartlet (played
by Martin Sheen) taking an obsessive interest
in a New Hampshire school board
election. The race was in the district
where Bartlet, a former New Hampshire governor,
sent his kids to public school. And the
leading candidate was Elliot Roush, a Christian
fundamentalist whom Bartlet beat in the
first election of his political career.
With that story line already percolating,
Sorkin said he looked at the e-mail about Laura
and thought, "Gee, this is right for this
episode, and there's a way to dramatize it."
The result was a scene (below) in which
Bartlet used his own detailed knowledge of
the Bible to make the Schlessinger-esque
character Jenna Jacobs look ridiculous.
But Sorkin said he was troubled by his
use of the Internet material.
"If you're a writer," he said, "the only
thing worse than not getting credit for something
you did is getting credit for something
you didn't do."
So Sorkin mentioned the situation in a weekly
meeting of "West Wing" producers.
"I wanted to make sure that nobody thought
I was trying to pull a fast one,"
Sorkin said. "Being called a plagiarist
is like being called a sex offender. Even if it's not
true, once the stench is out there, it's
not easy to get rid of."
Staff members were assigned to try to identify
a specific author, and efforts
included asking questions in some of the
many anti-Schlessinger Internet chat
rooms and contacting gay-oriented publications
like The Advocate.
"We came up empty," Sorkin said, "except
that all the people we spoke to said they'd
seen several different versions of the
Laura/biblical] material over the last year or so."
Had the search been successful, Sorkin said,
the person would have received a
modest payment and some kind of on-screen
credit, even though lawyers had
advised him that he was under no such obligation.
* * * * * *
Faithfully Following The Script-ures
In last week's episode of "The West Wing,"
President Josiah Bartlet (Martin Sheen)
sarcastically confronted conservative radio
personality Jenna Jacobs (Claire Yarlett),
who alone remained seated when the President
appeared at an informal White House
reception for radio talk-show hosts.
Bartlet, an economist and former governor
of New Hampshire, possesses a precise
knowledge of biblical text.
Here is the tense and electric confrontation
between Bartlet and Jacobs.
President Josiah Bartlet: You're Dr. Jenna
Jacobs, right?
Dr. Laura-type character: Yes, Sir.
Bartlet: ...Forgive me, Dr. Jacobs. Are
you an M.D.?
Jacobs: A Ph.D.
Bartlet: A Ph.D.
Jacobs: Yes, Sir.
Bartlet: Psychology?
Jacobs: No, Sir.
Bartlet: Theology?
Jacobs: No.
Bartlet: Social work?
Jacobs: I have a Ph.D. in English literature.
Bartlet: I'm asking cuz on your show, people
call in for advice and you go
by the name Dr. Jacobs on your show, and
I didn't know if maybe your
listeners were confused by that and assumed
you had advanced training in
psychology, theology or health care.
Jacobs: I don't believe they are confused,
no, Sir.
Bartlet: Good. I like your show. I like
how you call homosexuality an abomination.
Jacobs: I don't say homosexuality is an
abomination, Mr. President, the Bible does.
Bartlet: Yes, it does. Leviticus.
Jacobs: 18:22.
Bartlet: Chapter and verse. I wanted to
ask you a couple of questions
while I had you here. I'm interested in
selling my youngest daughter into
slavery as sanctioned in Exodus 21:7.
She's a Georgetown sophomore,
speaks fluent Italian, always cleared the
table when it was her turn. What
would a good price for her be? While thinking
about that, can I ask
another? My chief of staff, Leo McGarry,
insists on working on the
sabbath. Exodus 35:2 clearly says he should
be put to death. Am I morally
obligated to kill him myself, or is it
OK to call the police? Here's one
that's really important cuz we've got a
lot of sports fans in this town.
Touching the skin of a dead pig makes one
unclean. Leviticus 11:7. If they
promise to wear gloves, can the Washington
Redskins still play football?
Can Notre Dame? Can West Point? Does the
whole town really have to be
together to stone my brother John for planting
different crops side-by-side?
Can I burn my mother in a small family gathering
for wearing garments
made from two different threads? Think
about those questions, would you?
One last thing, while you may mistaking
this for your monthly meeting of the
Ignorant Tight-ass Club, in this building,
when the President stands, nobody sits.
--Exchange between President Bartlet and
a character clearly meant to be
Dr. Laura Schlessinger, Oct. 18 on NBC-TV's
The West Wing.