A Program We Can Support
TV gets serious about politics — in 'West Wing'
By DAVID BIANCULLI Daily News TV Critic
It's a day before the presidential election, and the guy millions of
Americans would rather vote for isn't even on the ballot.
He's Josiah Bartlet, the admirable, Scripture-quoting incumbent
played by Martin Sheen on NBC's top-rated "The West Wing."
The man behind this President is writer-producer Aaron Sorkin, who did
the
script for the 1995 movie "The American President." Using the film's basic
framework, one of its supporting players (Sheen) and even the same set,
Sorkin has crafted a densely populated weekly drama about national politics
and the individuals who make policy, or try to.
It's a very intricate, intelligent, demanding series. It has also
gotten strong points for credibility, from the accuracy
of its set to the intricacies of give-and-take Washington
politics — though at least one D.C. insider gives it a mixed review.
"I find it interesting, but it's not totally realistic," says former
President Gerald Ford. "I think there's a degree of accuracy to it."
Directed by Thomas Schlamme and others, "The West Wing" is the political
equivalent of a roller coaster. Characters and ideas zip in and out faster
than interns
on "ER." In an age when irony is king on television, the show is almost
old-fashioned in its patriotism and idealism. And with its verbal and visual
elements equally frenetic, "The Wing Wing" is hardly a passing diversion.
And yet, at a time when real-world politics and politicians seem to bore
most people,
"The West Wing" is a colossal success. As of last week, it was tied (with
CBS'
"Everybody Loves Raymond") for fourth place for the TV season to date.
The most
recent episode was seen by more than 12 million people.
So how does a show that demands so much from its viewers become so popular?
Mike Donovan, professor of radio, TV and film at New Jersey's Rowan University,
concedes he isn't sure — that the inside-baseball level of the politics
in "The
West Wing" reminds him of another TV show he thought was too "different"
to
catch on: NBC's "Seinfeld."
"I thought the humor in 'Seinfeld' was so urban, so New York, I couldn't
imagine it
playing anywhere else," Donovan says. Similarly, he thinks "The West Wing"
is
"almost too smart for what I would believe most television viewers can
handle" —
though he's thrilled to be proven wrong.
"I think it's the most complex visual show on television," Donovan says.
"It's one of
those shows where you don't watch while reading the paper. You have to
actually
pay attention. But as a teacher and a viewer, I love that. If I can just
listen to a
TV show, then it's radio."
Bob Thompson, director of the Center for the Study of Popular Television
at
Syracuse University, has, like Donovan, shown "The West Wing" in classrooms
since its premiere last fall. And while marveling that TV writers in general
have
not made more use of national politics, Thompson also is amazed by the
show's
timing, as well as its contents.
With its unveiling in the fall of 1999 — "right on the heels," Thompson
notes, "of
the biggest soap-operatic TV-oriented political story of all time with
the Monica
[Lewinsky] stuff" — Thompson expected "The West Wing" to be "very 'Melrose
Place'-like, with all the sex and scandal and stuff."
Instead, it went for nobility and for politics with a purpose, fought by
characters who
were flawed but committed. Yes, deputy communications director Sam Seaborn
(played by Rob Lowe) slept with a prostitute, but he didn't know she was
one.
Yes, chief of staff Leo McGarry (John Spencer) has a substance-abuse problem,
but he confronted it years ago and was willing to go public with it. Yes,
press
secretary C.J. Cregg (Allison Janney) has a romantic relationship with
a White House
reporter, but on the job, both of them are totally professional. And, yes,
the President
is shown heatedly thinking about having sex in the West Wing — but with
his own
wife, played beautifully by Stockard Channing.
"I think the stroke of genius," Thompson says, "was that Sorkin and Co.
figured out
that the wave of irony and cynicism has crested, and they went the exact
opposite
direction — with this incredibly sincere and earnest Frank Capra-esque
sort of
presentation.
"When we talk about Washington and Hollywood having this battle for the
American soul, these so-called culture wars, it's no wonder Hollywood is
winning
it. Look at how political candidates — at any of the debates you want —
are so
totally incapable of talking in a style that suggests a degree of earnestness
and
sincerity that people can understand. They all sound like Charlie Brown's
teacher —
'Wha-wha-whaaa, wha-wha-whaaa.'
"And then you turn on 'The West Wing,' this fictional place, and you've
got all of these
people who, in fact, have developed language and imagery that can work
in the
post-Watergate, post-Monica era. And they can talk about politics in a
sincere way."
Politics in Earnest
Thompson cites a recent episode that ended with the staff members sitting
on a
stoop and saluting each other, and the country, with a heartfelt "God bless
America" toast.
"The scene was moving," Thompson says. "It made sense. What they've captured
on
this show — and most of it is due to Sorkin — is a type of language in
which we can
talk about our country, our nationhood, our citizenry, our responsibilities.
That we
can, in fact, take it all seriously again.
"I don't think the real Washington has figured out how to do that," he
adds, "and I
think therein lies the show's popularity."
Thompson pauses for a moment, just as President Bartlet does before making
his
final point, and adds, "As goofy as it sounds, Washington politicians could
do
very well to make an appointment every Wednesday night to watch episodes
of
'The West Wing' very carefully.
"If for no other reason than to learn how to talk."