Jan. 15, 2002 | WASHINGTON (AP) -- Even as Enron Corp. Chairman Kenneth Lay boasted to employees of the company's growth, one of them privately warned him in August of the reckless practices that eventually brought down the energy-trading giant.
"I am incredibly nervous that we will implode in a wave of accounting
scandals," the employee told Lay in a letter.
A "veil of secrecy" surrounded Enron's partnerships, which were keeping
huge amounts of Enron debt off the
company's books, she said.
"It sure looks to the layman on the street that we are hiding losses,"
wrote the employee, who was identified by
her Houston attorney as Sherron Watkins, Enron's vice president of
corporate development.
She said several senior Enron employees "consistently and constantly"
questioned the corporation's accounting
methods to senior Enron officials, including CEO Jeffrey Skilling.
Skilling resigned in August.
In a telephone interview Monday night, Watkins' attorney, Philip Hilder,
said Enron responded to the warning letter,
but he would provide no details.
Reps. Bill Tauzin, R-La., who is chairman of the House Energy and Commerce
Committee, and James Greenwood,
R-Pa., released excerpts from the letter to Lay on Monday. The two
lawmakers demanded from Enron all records
relating to a review of the employee's allegations as part of the panel's
investigation of Enron.
Around the time of the August letter, Lay was telling the 20,000-strong
work force that growth of the Houston-based
company "has never been more certain." Two months later, Lay was phoning
President Bush's Treasury and Commerce secretaries seeking help for Enron
as it careened toward collapse and its stock price slid.
Employees and retirees helplessly watched their life savings dissolve
last fall because the company prohibited them
from selling the Enron shares that comprised the bulk of their retirement
accounts.
The company entered the biggest corporate bankruptcy in U.S. history
on Dec. 2, leaving countless investors burned
and thousands of employees out of work.
Enron was the nation's seventh-largest company in revenue, and its collapse
has hurt both individual investors and big
pension funds around the country. Florida's fund, for example, has
lost more than $300 million. Also roiling the financial
system was the impact on major banks, which had lent billions to the
high-flying company that had been a darling of
Wall Street and viewed as a technological innovator.
As the company struggled to maintain its credit rating last fall, Lay,
who has been Bush's biggest campaign benefactor,
pointed out to Treasury Secretary Paul O'Neill the government's intervention
in 1998 to prevent the collapse of a big
hedge fund for wealthy investors.
O'Neill, along with Commerce Secretary Don Evans, have said that while
they received calls from Lay in late October
and early November, they dismissed any suggestion of intervening to
help the company.
Given the magnitude of the troubles at Enron, "I think they (administration
officials) had an obligation to be public
about the controversy," said Paul Light, director of government studies
at the Brookings Institution, a think tank.
The White House should have disclosed the Enron phone contacts to the news media immediately, Light suggested.
O'Neill and Evans have said they saw no need to inform Bush of the October-November
telephone conversations
they had with Lay.
White House spokesman Ari Fleischer has said that, as far as he knows,
nobody at the White House was told of
calls from Lay to Bush Cabinet secretaries. Evans said Sunday he had
told Andrew Card, White House chief of staff,
but that Card never informed the president.
Fears of a conflict of interest involving a big Bush donor may have
led to administration officials' not wanting to
intervene in Enron's behalf, some analysts suggested.
Because of Enron's heavy donations to Bush's campaigns, administration
officials "were tied at the hip to Enron,"
said Bill Allison, an official of the private Center for Public Integrity.
That made it hard to help.
"The appearance would have looked terrible," Allison said. "They felt
that they couldn't act on behalf of Enron
because of the political fallout."
In related developments:
--Tauzin and Greenwood said senior Enron officials instructed the law
firm of Vinson & Elkins to review the
employee's allegations, but told the outside attorneys not to second-guess
accounting advice and not to analyze
the questioned transactions in detail.
--Enron's auditing firm, Arthur Andersen LLP, said an in-house lawyer
spelled out Andersen's document destruction
policy for auditors on Oct. 12, four days before Enron announced third-quarter
losses of hundreds of millions of dollars.
The Andersen lawyer, Nancy Temple, e-mailed the policy to a partner
in the firm's office in Houston, where Enron is based.
Andersen is under scrutiny for destroying thousands of documents related to Enron last fall.
--Enron's Washington attorney, Robert Bennett, said Lay will testify
Feb. 4 in his first appearance before Congress
since the scandal broke.