U2
- Madison Square Garden, New York 10/11/05
Beautifully staged, great lighting and video.
Very moving in spots, very congregational and
they love the audience and the
audience loves them back. Tough New Yorkers singing
every word for the whole
show, and that's a lot of words, many of them
the most sensitive poetry in rock.
Great story by Bono about coming across the Brooklyn
Bridge from JFK and
seeing the city for the first time, asking the
manager (Frank Barsalona, a legendary
genius) how they could afford the ridiculous
long car...manager explains that they
are going to do it just like the Beatles start
in New York and fan out across the
country from there... And Edge saying, "Well
boys, we're the toppermost of the
poppermost," (quote from Beatles bio). At the
time they were 16, 17 thereabouts.
The next night they played at the Palladium, their
first US appearance, in 1980.
I was there. Hearing Bono tell this story 25
years later was overwhelming and
I stood there 52 years old crying like a child
and totally unashamed.
The tattooed Bronx bruiser on my right patted
my back and we smiled.
The presentation was spectacular, and again, the
lights were innovative, and
beautiful, and well integrated into the show.
There was one very cool video
moment where Bono (playing a blue Gretsch Country
Gentleman) dissolves into
pixelated shimmer,then as they zoom in on the
pixels it becomes clear they are a
mosaic of faces, then it becomes clear that they
are faces in the crowd at the show.
5 cameras. Flawless. The production was the best
I've ever seen.
Evans was fabulous, had a really great night,
spraying sparks and shimmering rainbows
from a variety of really cool axes, including
a cream original Les Paul PAF blackpickguard,
through several excellent thoroughly recent and
modern Stratocasters, and a really good
sounding Tele. Oh yeah and a Gibson Hummingbird
and Dove, just to drive me totally crazy.
How they manage to maintain such precise intonation
on the strats I have no clue.
His tech was in a sunken room built into the
stage to his right and was a pretty busy guy.
I'd love to understand his pedal board and preamp
rack and how all those AC30s and little
Fenders are wired up. He did have one of the
Vox Valvetronix modeling amps and used it
a fair amount.
Bono was self-effacing, almost goofy, a country
boy in the city... Very humble and in awe
of New York and how far they had come. The political
stuff was less forced than I'd thought
it would be. The audience is behind him, so he
doesn't exhort. Smart. Last 20 minutes were
pretty thick with proselytizing, but who cares.
Hard to disagree with, and he didn't come off
like a dickhead.
Bad news: The rhythm section unfortunately never
really takes off. Ever. They are just too stiff
and restrained for the show to attain the exuberant
heights that Edge and Bono try for.
Very careful, dogged and robotic. But. There's
a great military and tribal subtext in the
drumming, and he obviously didn't win All-Ireland
Band Drummer in 1978 for nothing.
I just wish he and Adam would loosen up. The
whole sound is bright and thin, and could use
a little more Motown bottom end push, to really
make it a universal sound. As it is, it's pretty
white, and more brilliante than soulful.
IT was a great night, tho, and I plan to hit one
of the Fleet Center shows in December.
Jamie |